Posted On: December 31, 2008

Tractor trailer wreck on I-85 Georgia due to bad tire

This morning on I-85 near Newnan, Georgia, a tractor trailer wrecked due to a blown tire. A 72-year-old trucker driving a 1996 International 4000 tractor-trailer crashed when a right tire reportedly blew on the vehicle, causing him to lose control and strike a guardrail. Fortunately, no injuries were reported. It was a local truck delivering concrete forms.

Most of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations have been adopted for intrastate trucking within Georgia. The FMCSR, at 49 CFR 396.13, requires the driver to make a pre-trip inspection and sign a report noting any defect in equipment. The FMCSR at 49 CFR 392.7, specifies that the pre-trip inspection driver must confirm that the following are in good working order: service brakes, including trailer brake connections; parking (hand) brake; steering mechanism; lighting devices and reflectors; tires; horn; windshield wiper or wipers; rear-vision mirror or mirrors; coupling devices.

Continue reading " Tractor trailer wreck on I-85 Georgia due to bad tire " »

Posted On: December 30, 2008

Recession ends truck driver shortage

For years we have been hearing about a severe shortage of qualified over the road truck drivers, contributing to widespread safety concerns.

Now the severe economic recession has cut into shipping volume, led to an ongoing consolidation of the trucking industry, and a glut of qualified drivers, as reported by Rick Rommell of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.

This is just the latest "bad news / good news" story in the interesting times in which we live.

Continue reading " Recession ends truck driver shortage " »

Posted On: December 28, 2008

Firefighter crushed under tractor trailer speeding in freezing rain in Indiana

A tractor trailer accident on an icy interstate highway in Indiana underscores the importance of the rule requiring drivers of commercial vehicles to exercise "extreme caution" in hazardous weather conditions.

On I-74 in Indiana, a firefighter was suffered a crushed pelvis, broken leg, and multiple internal injuries when he was struck and pinned under the rear drive axle of a tractor trailer as it came to a rest in the soggy ditch of the icy interstate. Police said the accident happened while I-74 was covered with ice after freezing rain fell. Sheriff Ken Campbell added: "Emergency responders are put at an unnecessary risk by motorists who insist on driving too fast in these road conditions."


49 CFR 392.14 requires:

Extreme caution in the operation of a commercial motor vehicle shall be exercised when hazardous conditions, such as those caused by snow, ice, sleet, fog, mist, rain, dust, or smoke, adversely affect visibility or traction. Speed shall be reduced when such conditions exist. If conditions become sufficiently dangerous, the operation of the commercial motor vehicle shall be discontinued and shall not be resumed until the commercial motor vehicle can be safely operated. Whenever compliance with the foregoing provisions of this rule increases hazard to passengers, the commercial motor vehicle may be operated to the nearest point at which the safety of passengers is assured.

As a truck driver client recently told me, it's better to pull over in bad weather than to unnecesarily risk injury or death to himself or others.

Continue reading " Firefighter crushed under tractor trailer speeding in freezing rain in Indiana " »

Posted On: December 28, 2008

Yawning Danger - call to take truckers back to 10 hours driving per day

Truck driver fatigue as a cause of major tractor trailer accidents is an old story. As a trucking trial lawyer in Atlanta, Georgia, I have seen it too many times.

In today's Baltimore Sun, there is an editorial, "Yawning Danger," urging the incoming Obama administration to overturn the hours of service rule that is set to become permanent on the last day of the Bush administration. The old rule limited truck drivers to 10 hours of driving in one day. The current temporary rule, which will become "permanent" on January 19th, allows driving 11 hours during 14 hours on duty.

The editorial points out:

Has the 11th hour made the roads more dangerous? Are 11th-hour drivers more likely to be involved in crashes? Some research suggests no, and that's the evidence sited by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration when it granted the rule change in November. But advocates say the government's analysis relies heavily on one study from the Virginia Tech Transportation Institute that is deeply flawed (depending, for instance, on truckers being videotaped; the presence of a camera onboard likely affected their performance).

The bulk of 35 years of research, the petitioners point out, shows that the performance of long-haul truck drivers diminishes even before the 10-hour limit is reached. And while the number of highway fatalities was down the last two years, it went up the first year the new rules were in place. Recent safety improvements to roads and vehicles as well as lower average highway speeds may be masking the effect of the longer hours.

It seems like common sense that fatigue is progressive, and that one is more fatigued and more accident prone in the 11th hour of driving than in the 10th hour.

Continue reading " Yawning Danger - call to take truckers back to 10 hours driving per day " »

Posted On: December 27, 2008

Quick clips: what they're saying about prospective DOT Secretary Ray LaHood

Trucking safety lawyers as well as everyone else concerned about transportation issues needs to pay attention to personnel choices in the US Department of Transportation. You remember the old cliche that "personnel is policy." Even an humble personal injury trial attorney handling trucking accident cases in Atlanta should be attentive.

President-elect Obama has picked Ray LaHood, a retiring Republican congressman from rural Illinois as his Secretary of Transportation. Here's what some of the commentators around the country are saying:

* John Hughes and Julianna Goldman at Bloomberg.com write:

Even with firm Democratic majorities in the House and Senate, Obama will need help across the aisle. Legislation to upgrade the nation’s air-traffic control system has been stuck in Congress for more than a year and the Bush administration has been fighting airlines over flight rights in New York. Meanwhile, Obama is planning to give states an infusion of funds to create jobs by improving the nation’s infrastructure. . . .
In an attempt to cut through partisan rancor in the late 1990’s, LaHood organized a series of annual retreats -- at resorts a short train or car ride outside of Washington -- to bring together lawmakers and their families.

* In The New Republic, John B. Judis writes "LaHood and Solis: Second Round Picks":

Bush’s administration. But they should be important in Obama’s administration. Transportation has a stake in America’s two biggest manufacturing industries, planes and auto. Much of the $900 billion and rising in infrastructure funding is going to go through the Transportation Department. The secretary is not just going to be responsible for shepherding this spending through Congress, but also for shaping what kind of spending occurs. What gets funded--highways, airports, rail, mass transit--and in what proportion will determine what the country looks like well into the next decades. LaHood is being touted as being pro-rail because he didn’t vote against AMTRAK, but I have heard little to convince me that he will bring any kind of vision to the job or that he will able to sell controversial provisions in the Senate.
* National Journal's Expert Blog on transportation issues includes a collection of comments from figures in aviation, highway construction, etc. There is no end to lobbyists.

* John O'Dell at Green Car Advisor on Edmunds.com writes:

LaHood has little transportation record beyond his support for Amtrak, the national passenger train program, and his apparently friendly relationship with the Teamsters Union and other transportation unions, which endorsed and financially supported him during his congressional career. The national Teamseters Union also has endorsed his nomination as Transportation Secretary.

* American Traffic Safety Services Association (ATSSA) is the industry organization of companies providing pavement markings, road signs, work zone traffic control devices, guardrail, and other roadside safety features. It issued a statement that it was "is enthused by the selection and recommends prompt confirmation from the Senate."

* Oliver Patton at TruckingInfo.com wrote that LaHood will "have to hit the ground running: Obama has called for massive public works investments, in the short term for economic stimulus and in the longer term for rebuilding and modernizing transportation infrastructure."


Continue reading " Quick clips: what they're saying about prospective DOT Secretary Ray LaHood " »

Posted On: December 27, 2008

Big rig and snow removal truck crash in NH reminds me of my first trucking case in GA

A truck wreck in New Hampshire sounds similar to the the first interstate trucking personal injury case I handled as a "puppy lawyer" about 25 years ago, before I learned the basics of anything as fundamental as the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations.

In the New Hampshire accident this morning, a state snow plow truck on I-89 was struck in the rear by a tractor trailer. The tractor trailer driver was hospitalized for a head injury.

My case a quarter century ago arose out of a rare Georgia snow storm after Christmas. A Georgia DOT snow removal truck was outfitted with a blade in the front and salt spreader in back. With two workers in the cab, it was moving slowly clearing snow next to the median barrier. A flatbed tractor trailer running empty on the way home Texas was traveling way too fast, skidded on an icy spot, and skidded into the DOT truck. The Texas trucker clearly was not exercising the "extreme caution" required of commercial trucks in hazardous weather conditions.

The fellow "riding shotgun" in the DOT vehicle wasn't hurt significantly in the initial impact, but was trapped, wedged between the median barrier and the 18 wheeler, when the snow removal truck caught fire. By the time someone broke out the windshield and pulled him to safety, he had second and third degree burns over much of his body. The case was a learning experience for me in that it was my first case involving a serious burn injury.

Continue reading " Big rig and snow removal truck crash in NH reminds me of my first trucking case in GA " »

Posted On: December 26, 2008

Quick clips on Boxing Day: trucking economics and safety

Taking a break from trucking accident litigation on the day after Christmas, I'm sitting at home in Atlanta, in a house where it seems everyone else is either sleeping or out bargain hunting, reading the news.

A few quick notes on the news as it relates to the trucking industry safety and economics, which in turn ultimately affects safety:

* Three members of a Duluth, Georgia, family were killed on Christmas Eve when they were rearended by a tractor trailer on the Pennsylvania Turnpike en route to New York. Benito Rivera, Christina Rivera-Morales and their four year old child were killed. Their two year old survived. One report says this happened in freezing rain, the sort of adverse weather that requires that truckers operate with "extreme caution." According to another report, the family vehicle had lost control and come to rest across the traffic lane in the dark. Let's remember that family in our prayers, as well as the overstressed and underpaid trucker who probably hit them while trying to get home for Christmas with his family, and hold our own loved ones tight.

* YRC Worldwide parent company of Yellow Freight, cancelled a $150 million tender offer and is negotiating for easier terms on its credit lines as its shares dropped 18% and Moody's cut its credit rating. The carrier's freight tonnage was down substantially -- 11%, 12% 21% depending on how the counting is done -- from last year YRC was also negotiating a sale-leaseback of a portion of its facilities.

* Navistar International,manufacturer of trucks, buses, and diesel engines, is restating its net income upward due to an accounting error. While reported earning were up, the stock went down. The company benefited from higher military revenue and demand for more fuel efficient trucks, offsetting some of the decline in general trucking demand.

* The Wall Street Journal in a lead editorial blasted prospective DOT Secretary Ray LaHood as "Obama's Secretary of Earmarks," criticizing him for having "facilitatated the incontinent spending that helped Republicans lose their majority...." That is followed by an editorial titled "...And Bridges to Everywhere," lampooning some spending projects proposed by local governments. Let's hope that the new infrastructure spending will be more like Ike's building of the interstate highway system in my youth, investing in our children's future.

* California has passed the nation's strictest rules on diesel fuel emissions. While my son may breathe marginally cleaner air near L.A., the increased cost for truckers to comply comes at a very difficult time.

* In another California story, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration announced on Christmas Eve a ruling that the hours of service rules for interstate truckers do not preempt California laws and regulations requiring employers to provide employees with meal and rest breaks.

* The U.S. isn't the only country where the economic slowdown is affecting trucking. In India, about 158,000 commercial trucks went back to the lenders in December alone.

Continue reading " Quick clips on Boxing Day: trucking economics and safety " »

Posted On: December 26, 2008

Gasoline tanker crashes and explodes on Lookout Mountain

Driving a gasoline tanker truck is one of the most dangerous and nerve-racking of occupations. I have heard from tanker truck drivers that they live in constant amprehension of disaster. After a relatively minor collision, their stress may suffer a form of post-traumatic stress disorder from contemplation of the close call.

This week a gasoline tanker truck operated by Florida Rock and Tanklines crashed and burned on Georgia Highway 157 on Lookout Mountain, as reported by WTVC television in Chattanooga. The driver was killed in the resulting explosion and fire.

Highway 157 is a beautiful route through a bucolic mountaintop landscape. Until I was 12 I lived at Mentone, Alabama, on top of Lookout Mountain, and went to school at Menlo, Georgia, in Shinbone Valley, so the site of this fiery crash is just a few miles north of the route I rode to school every day.

Posted On: December 24, 2008

Trucker killed in collision with another tractor trailer in Iowa

Handling a lot of truck and bus accident cases in my law practice in Georgia, I often see cases where there are truckers on both sides of the case, as one tractor trailer crashes into another tractor trailer. It drives home the fact that truck driving is a hazardous occupation.

This week's news included another of those incidents, this time on I-80 in Iowa. Saturday about 7:30 P.M., an unidentified truck driver was killed when he rearended another truck, and his tractor caught fire. The driver of the lead truck was injured.

Continue reading " Trucker killed in collision with another tractor trailer in Iowa " »

Posted On: December 23, 2008

GPS data to be used to monitor trucking companies' compliance with federal regulations

As a trucking safety trial lawyer, I've been bemused at the reluctance to fully utilize widely available GPS technology for trucking regulatory enforcement. Under a policy issued in 1997, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration limited the use of technology data and electronically produced records, such as GPS, during reviews and for regulatory enforcement purposes.

Now, effective 12/19/08,according to a report by Barb Kampbell at TheTrucker.com the FMCSA will use GPS and other advanced technology for regulatory enforcement and safety reviews.

Continue reading " GPS data to be used to monitor trucking companies' compliance with federal regulations " »

Posted On: December 21, 2008

Safety management a key to trucking industry profitability

Seldom does my trucking litigation practice as an attorney in Atlanta overlap with my semi-regular reading of Investors Business Daily. However, the issue for Monday, 12/22/08, includes an insightful article by J. Bonasia titled "Trucking Firms Shift Gears."

Some key points:


* "A central part of the industry's cost structure involves a focus on safety, which is the main differentiator among trucking firms."

* "All trucking firms pay roughly the same amount for fuel, trucks, drivers and equipment, . . . .So the real difference is the quality of people who deliver the service and their safety record. That can prevent a company from being bitten by losses due to accidents."

* Advantages of GPS tracking system for efficient fleet management and auxillary power units for energy conservation.

* Consolidation of the trucking industry in the current economic contraction as smaller and less well managed companies fail.

So it's not just plaintiffs' lawyers (that nasty breed constantly berated by IBD) and wingnut safety crusaders who recognize that safety is crucial to profitability. Business analysts too recognize that safety management is critical to profitability in the trucking industry.

Continue reading " Safety management a key to trucking industry profitability " »

Posted On: December 21, 2008

Hours of service rule for truckers challenged as threat to safety

As a trucking trial attorney, I see case after case of fatigued truck drivers, either near the end of their legal hours of service, or pushing beyond those hours, causing crashes due to impaired perception, reaction and judgment. For the past several years there has been a battle over extension of legal driving hours from 10 hours to 11 hours during a 14 hour shift.

A group of trucking safety and truck driver organizations have challenged the current administration's effort to make the current hours of service rule permanent on President Bush's last day in office.

The final rule, which is scheduled to take effect on Jan. 19, allows truckers to drive up to 11 hours out of 14 hours on duty in a single shift, while driving 88 hours or working 98 hours over eight consecutive days.

The organizations joining in filing a petition for reconsideration of the rule include Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety, Public Citizen, Truck Safety Coalition, and International Brotherhood of Teamsters. They previously won two court rulings against the rule, only to see the FMCSA reissue essentially the same rule.

The petition for reconsideration asks FMCSA to reconsider the regulation based on errors and misrepresentations of research findings showing that much longer working and driving hours will produce severely fatigued drivers who also can suffer serious health problems from excessively long working hours.

Jacqueline Gillan, vice president of Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety, said “FMCSA simply disregarded scores of studies conducted over more than 30 years showing that this incredibly demanding working and driving schedule will lead to exhausted truck drivers who literally can fall asleep at the wheels of their rigs.”

John Lannen, executive director of the Truck Safety Coalition, stated “FMCSA has issued a regulation that just doesn’t care about the health and safety of truck drivers, much less anyone else sharing the road with them. The agency attempted to justify this bankrupt regulation by manipulating the enormous body of facts and science that clearly shows that truck drivers, like other workers, cannot perform safely day after day, week after week, under these incredible working schedules. This rule threatens the personal safety of everyone on America’s roads.”

Continue reading " Hours of service rule for truckers challenged as threat to safety " »

Posted On: December 19, 2008

Georgia tort reform inadvertently puts brakes on a common defense tactic

As a trucking trial lawyer in Georgia, I often encounter defendants seeking to exclude evidence of corporate misconduct by just admitting that that they are responsible for the driver. Rather than letting into evidence the whole story of the corporation's systemic disregard for safety for years, they try to focus on a couple of second on the road and then engage in subtle character assassination against the person who is injured or killed.

For a long time that worked. But now, as an illustration of the law of unintended consequences, tort reform may bring an end to that tactic.

The General Assembly of Georgia in 2005 passed a tort reform bill that includes O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33, as follows:

(b) Where an action is brought against more than one person for injury to person or property, the trier of fact, in its determination of the total amount of damages to be awarded, if any, shall after a reduction of damages pursuant to subsection (a) of this Code section, if any, apportion its award of damages among the persons who are liable according to the percentage of fault of each person. Damages apportioned by the trier of fact as provided in this Code section shall be the liability of each person against whom they are awarded, shall not be a joint liability among the persons liable, and shall not be subject to any right of contribution.

In other states that similarly require allocation of fault between defendants, courts have held that the jury may be required to allocate percentages of fault between an employee driver and his employer against whom separate claims similar to negligent training, entrustment, hiring and supervision are made.

In Tennessee, “negligent entrustment does not create vicarious liability and the jury must allocate fault between the defendants.” Ali v. Fisher, 145 S.W.3d 557, 564 (Tenn., 2004).

In Kansas, “fault in a negligent entrustment case must be apportioned between the entrustor and the entrustee.” McCart v. Muir, 230 Kan. 618, 641 P.2d 384 (1982).

In Texas, evidence that a driver trainer had only a weekend training course and never failed a trainee, and released a truck driver to drive solo before the terminal manager approved him to drive solo was sufficient to constitute a jury question on a claim of negligent training. Builders Transport v. Grice-Smith, 167 S.W.3d 1 (Tex. App. - Waco, 2005)


Continue reading " Georgia tort reform inadvertently puts brakes on a common defense tactic " »

Posted On: December 19, 2008

Tractor trailer rearended by airplane

Even I as a trucking accident trial lawyer can't figure a way to blame this one on the trucking company.

According to a report by Kevin Valentine on Wearecentralpa.com, Friday on the Pennsylvania Turnpike, a small airplane rearended a tractor trailer and bounced over the guardrail before coming to rest.

Continue reading " Tractor trailer rearended by airplane " »

Posted On: December 19, 2008

New EPA administrator is a certified HazMat manager

As a trucking trial attorney occasionally representing truck drivers who are injured as well as others who are injured by by truckers, I have been fascinated by the stories I hear from HazMat drivers about the dangers they face every day. Those folks ought to qualify for combat pay.

Lisa P. Jackson has been selected as administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency in the upcoming Obama administration. She has served as commissioner of the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection and worked for 16 years in the Superfund Program at EPA. She earned the Certified Hazardous Materials Manager credential from the Institute of Hazardous Materials Management.

Continue reading " New EPA administrator is a certified HazMat manager " »

Posted On: December 19, 2008

New safety rules issued for intermodal trucking equipment

In my trucking litigation practice, I have found that one of the weak links in truck transportation is the quality of equipment used in transporting freight containers from ports to ultimate destinations. Too many of the truck chassis used are apparently old trailers spray painted to look sharp but with inadequate mechanical and safety features, and too many of the key players in the system were not subject to safety regulations.

Now the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration has issued proposed rules to augment safety requirements for intermodal container chassis—the trailers that transport cargo containers when they are transferred from ship or rail to truck for final delivery. The new regulations for the first time make intermodal equipment providers subject to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations (FMCSRs), and define shared safety responsibility among intermodal equipment providers, motor carriers, and drivers.

A spokesman for the American Trucking Association noted that this will mark the first time that intermodal equipment providers have been required to maintain their equipment and be responsible for it, as motor carriers are required to maintain their equipment.

The Intermodal Association of America expressed reservations. The organization said it is disappointed that the rules failed:

* to recognize existing industry standards and processes that could have been utilized to facilitate the objectives of the regulations;

* to clarify what party would be considered the “IEP” for purposes of regulatory compliance and in fact might have “muddied the water”;

* to accept the existing alpha/numeric equipment identification number; and

* to definitively accept the industry solution of a Web-based intermodal equipment registry as an alternative to physically marking/labeling equipment with a new DOT number.

IANA said it will consider filing a petition for reconsideration upon completion of a thorough review of all provisions of the rules and the projected impact on intermodal industry participants.

Continue reading " New safety rules issued for intermodal trucking equipment " »

Posted On: December 18, 2008

The 11 deadly sins for trucking companies

As a trucking accident trial lawyer in Atlanta, I am no longer surprised at the failure of some trucking companies to do pretty basic stuff related to safety. Of course, I am looking at those companies whose drivers get into serious crashes.

Now the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration has published a new proposed rule on safety audits for new entrants in the motor carrier business. The FMCSA identified 11 regulatory violations which "reflect a clear lack of basic safety management controls" and which under the proposed rule would result in an automatic failure of the safety audit.

It is interesting to compare this list with the issues in recent cases, includingClarendon v. Johnson in which one judge of the Georgia Court of Appeals wrote an opinion concluding, in effect, that interstate motor carriers can exempt themselves from all safety and financial responsibility requirements of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations through their own violation (by way of the carrier's designated agent) of the regulation requiring execution of truck leases when they hire owner-operators to haul freight under the carrier's authority.

It was the first case in the United States in more than 50 years that gives motor carriers such free rein to disregard the rules and hide behind an "independent contractor" arrangement with an informally hired driver. An untold number of innocent people on the highways will be killed or maimed due to the Georgia Court of Appeals ruling, and will have no remedy.

The 11 deadly sins for trucking companies under the FMCSA proposal are:

1. Sec. 382.115(a)/Sec. 382.115(b)--Failing to implement an alcohol and/or controlled substances testing program (domestic and foreign motor carriers, respectively).

[Just a couple of days ago I took the deposition of a trucking company owner who never, ever required any drug testing of any driver -- preemployment, random or post-accident.]

2. Sec. 382.211--Using a driver who has refused to submit to an alcohol or controlled substances test required under part 382.

3. Sec. 382.215--Using a driver known to have tested positive for a controlled substance.

[Last week I took the deposition of a bus company that avoided getting a post-accident drug test of its driver, even though a professional psychologist who was an eyewitness immediately reported to police that the bus driver -- who had felony drug convictions and had just completed a residential drug treatment program as a condition of sentencing in another state -- was driving erratically, had a wild look in the eyes, and appeared to be on drugs.]

4. Sec. 383.37(a)--Knowingly allowing, requiring, permitting, or authorizing an employee with a commercial driver's license which is suspended, revoked, or canceled by a State or who is disqualified to operate a commercial motor vehicle.

[In Johnson v. Clarendon, an interstate motor carrier, through its designated agent, hired a driver who never even had a CDL because he was permanently disqualified, but the Georgia Court of Appeals thought that was just fine, so long as the motor carrier also violates the regulation that requires that it execute a truck lease when it hires a non-owned truck. In Georgia, violation of the lease requirement now gives a scofflaw carrier a free pass to ignore all the rest of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations with regard to informally hired trucks and drivers.]

5. Sec. 383.51(a)--Knowingly allowing, requiring, permitting, or authorizing a driver to drive who is disqualified to drive a commercial motor vehicle.

[See 8, below.]

6. Sec. 387.7(a)--Operating a motor vehicle without having in effect the required minimum levels of financial responsibility coverage.

[See 4 & 5, above. No problem according to one judge on the Georgia Court of Appeals.]

7. Sec. 391.15(a)--Using a disqualified driver.

[See 8, below.]

8. Sec. 391.11(b)(4)--Using a physically unqualified driver.

[See 4 above. A three-judge panel on the Georgia Court of Appeals had no problem with an interstate motor carrier, through an agent who was deemed under the FMCSR to be part of the motor carrier, casually hiring a driver to haul freight for the carrier who was permanently disqualified from driving a commercial motor vehicle due to being blind in one eye. That is just fine, under this ruling, so long as the motor carrier also avoids executing the required written lease and avoids using the word "lease" in its informal arrangement to hire the truck and driver.]

9. Sec. 395.8(a)--Failing to require a driver to make a record of duty status.

[Earlier this week I took the deposition of a trucking company owner who had never looked at the logs of the driver of a leased truck, dispatched by the company owner and operating with the carrier's logo and DOT number on the truck. The company owner was either too careless or too clueless to require or audit driver logs.]

10. Sec. 396.9(c)(2)--Requiring or permitting the operation of a commercial motor vehicle declared "out-of-service" before repairs are made.

11. Sec. 396.17(a)--Using a commercial motor vehicle not periodically inspected.

[We often find in depositions that motor carriers fail to require drivers to inspect trucks and fail to ever check to determine whether they performed inspections. Under the Johnson v. Clarendon ruling, the Georgia Court of Appeals would say that the motor carrier has no duty to assure compliance with truck inspection rules so long as it also omits a lease and use of the word "lease" in its informal arrangement.]

Don't get me wrong. I also represent some very fine, professional truck drivers who are conscientious about following the rules, and who work for companies that follow the rules. Truckers are generally no better or worse than lawyers or judges. A few bad ones made the rest look bad.


Continue reading " The 11 deadly sins for trucking companies " »

Posted On: December 18, 2008

Congressman Ray LaHood Named New US DOT Secretary

Setting the direction of trucking safety will be a small part of the job of the new Secretary of Transportation, Ray LaHood, named yesterday by President-elect Obama. He was not on the short list of candidates about whom there had been a lot of speculation. John McCain has praised the choice.

After reading about Lahood, I don't agree with those who speculate that this indicates low priority for transportation in the new administration. My hunch is that he was chosen to drum up bipartisan Congressional support for funding of major transportation infrastructure projects that Obama plans to help jumpstart the economy.

There are a few clues to how people associated with trucking view him. Land Line quotes Rod Nofziger, Director of Government Affairs for the Owner Operator Independent Drivers Association, as saying, "Mr. LaHood would be an excellent pick by the Obama administration. It’s very encouraging and would be a great thing for small-business truckers.” He got some campaign contributions from the American Trucking Association, and got a 100% rating for voting with the ATA.

LaHood is an Arab-American Republican Congressman who for 14 years has represented the area around Springfield and Peoria, Illinois. He did not run for another term in 2008. According to Jeff Zeleny at the New York Times, LaHood has experience on the House Appropriations Committee relevant to oversight of the sort of large-scale public spending on infrastructure projects. He also has close bipartisan relationships with President-elect Obama and Chief of Staff Designate Rahm Emanual..

Mike Dorning at The Swamp blog quotes Emanue's recent comments on the House floor about LaHood:

If you look back and I think if you ask all our colleagues, somebody when our framers thought of a member of Congress what they had in their mind's eye, that person would be Ray LaHood, whose decency, his sense of what it is that he was doing here on behalf of who he was doing it for never changed in his 30 years. He is an individual who, while firm in his principles, was very flexible about his opinions.

LaHood also has long been a favorite of reporters covering the Capitol for his willingness to say on-the-record what other members of Congress will only whisper anonymously.

A story on ABC News lists some of the priorities facting the US DOT, and does not list anything at the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. It includes:

- Upgrading the nation's transportation infrastructure - roads, bridges, etc. -- even though the Highway Trust Fund is running on fumes. The gas tax has become a less viable way of funding highways, so increased use of tolls with an EZ-Pass system may be considered.

- Upgrading Amtrak rail system.

- Upgrade the Federal Aviation Administrations' air traffic control system, relief of air traffic congestion, and aircraft inspection.

- Promotion of more fuel efficient vehicles, in conjunction with the proposed bailout of the auto industry.

Evan Sparks at Aviation Blog predicts that the appointment of LaHood may mean that Obama does not plan to devote a great deal of attention to transportation issues — much like our current president, whose cabinet’s token Democrat was also at DOT.

Andy Birkey at the Minnesota Independent gives some hometown insight on LaHood due to having grown up in Peoria. He reports that LaHood is of Lebanese Christian family background. He refused to sign Newt Gingrich's "Contract with America" in '94, supported the impeachment of President Clinton, is a close friend of Rahm Emanuel (Obama's chief of staff), supported subsidies for Amtrak, and voted for recent legislation to promote public transit.

Some bloggers have been critical of the appointment. Robert Cruikshank at California High Speed Rail Blog observed that "LaHood doesn't appear to have much of a record as a transportation expert."

Marcus Sanford at Austin Bike Blog noted that LaHood is a member of the Congressional Bike Caucus and has voted in favor of higher fuel standards, Amtrak funding, and renewable energy.

As for LaHood's campaign contributions from special interests of the years, you can figure that out for yourself.

As a "redneck lawyer" from Georgia, I know that leaders can transcend their backgrounds when promoted to new positions. Ray Lahood has been a congressman from a rural and small town district in downstate Illinois, where Caterpillar is the main industry. While big national issues such as urban transit, air travel safety and for that matter motor carrier safety have not been big vote getters in his district, he has shown interest in upgrading transportation. Obama and Emanuel know him well and apparently think he has capacity for growth and effectiveness.

We just need to make sure he is educated about trucking safety issues.

Continue reading " Congressman Ray LaHood Named New US DOT Secretary " »

Posted On: December 16, 2008

A day full of trucker depositions

As a trucking accident trial lawyer in Georgia, I find myself spending a lot of time in conference rooms for the depositions of truck drivers and trucking company owners. Since I sometimes represent truck drivers who are injured by the negligence of other truck drivers, it is not uncommon to spend a very long day with truckers on both sides of the table.

At this point few things surprise me. A few examples from depositions this week in a small town far from the nearest interstate highway:

* An owner of a certified interstate motor carrier for ten years was completely unaware that a motor carrier is responsible for leased trucks, the drivers of which are deemed to be employees of the motor carrier. That has only been the law since 1956. It is amazing how many people in the trucking business -- and how many judges -- are totally unaware.

* A motor carrier that never did anything to verify driving records or prior employment, never required drug tests, never maintained driver qualification files, never required drivers to agree to follow the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations, and never audited driver logs.

* A truck driver who thought he was still legal to drive 17 hours and 45 minutes after he reported for duty at 3:30 AM. The federal hours of service regulation limits truckers to driving 11 hours out of 14 hours on duty.

* A plaintiff truck driver who was appalled at the degree of ignorance of the trucking business on the part of the carrier and driver that slammed into him, costing him many months of lost wages and the necessity of surgery.

The defendants don't seem like bad guys. Just untrained and uninformed. As one of them said, the case was a "wakeup call." It's an expensive way to learn.

Continue reading " A day full of trucker depositions " »

Posted On: December 13, 2008

Forklift on tractor trailer takes chunk out of Texas overpass

I've been working on trucking accidents in the Atlanta, Georgia, area for a long time. Today's news includes a report of an accident in Arlington, Texas, that reminds me of my first tractor trailer wreck case.

According to a report by Lita Beck of the NBC affiliate station in Dallas - Fort Worth, an 18-wheeler hauling a forklift hit the State Highway 360 overpass Wednesday night, taking a chunk of the overpass near Six Flags Over Texas.

Back in the mid-1980's when I was an associate at an insurance defense law firm in Atlanta, I was assigned to defend a trucking company that was hauling a construction crane up I-75 in Cobb County when the crane boom came loose and started extending upward. The boom crashed into the Windy Hill Road bridge, wreaking havoc and allegedly moving the bridge over an inch or two.

No one was injured, but someone at the Georgia Department of Transportation saw an opportunity to get the trucking company's insurer to help pay for a new bridge that was planned. When GDOT sued for the cost of a new bridge, I served a notice to take the deposition of the then-commissioner of GDOT to examine him about the bridge plans, budget projections, etc. Before the date of the deposition, GDOT settled for the reasonable cost of repair -- not replacement -- of the old bridge.

Continue reading " Forklift on tractor trailer takes chunk out of Texas overpass " »

Posted On: December 10, 2008

Trucking industry capacity declining with recession

Bankruptcy (or mere shutdown) of 2,700 trucking companies in 2008 have put more than 127,000 trucks out of commission, cutting U.S. trucking capacity by 6.5 %, according to Donald Broughton, an analyst with the Avondale Partners research firm, as quoted by Mateusz Perkowski of Capital Press.

In previous economic downturns, trucks were simply mothballed and then returned to sevice when the economy improved. However, due to the weak dollar throughout much of 2008, there was a huge overseas demand for U.S. trucks. Many of the used trucks this year have been exported to Russia and Eastern Europe, resulting in more lost trucking capacity than in previous recessions.

The current contraction in trucking capacity may result in shipping demand quickly exceeding capacity when the economy recovers, so that trucking companies will be able to charge higher rates. Then, as they expand capacity to meet rising demand, they will be ordering new equipment with the next generation of fleet management and safety technology.

That should result in safer operations, fewer accidents and injuries in relation to the volume of traffic. But as we have been told so many times lately, it will get worse before it gets better.

Continue reading " Trucking industry capacity declining with recession " »

Posted On: December 9, 2008

Who will be new Secretary of Transportation and director of Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration?

As an attorney in Atlanta, Georgia, handling litigation resulting from accidents involving motor carriers (truck, bus, tractor trailer, big rigs, etc.), I have observed with interest the controversies about the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration in recent years. Looking ahead, it will be interesting to see who is picked to run the DOT and FMCSA in the next administration.

With many challenges regarding infrastructure, funding and technology, as well as safety rules and enforcement, personnel will be policy.

A report from Associated Press lists three likely candidates for Secretary of Transportation: Jane Garvey, former head of the Federal Aviation Administration. Mortimer Downey, former deputy transportation secretary. Steve Heminger, executive director, San Francisco Bay area transportation commission. Garvey and Downey are both on the Obama DOT transition team.

Garvey graduated from Mount St. Mary's College and earned an M.A. at Mount Holyoke. She was the first female FAA administrator. .Here is a copy of her testimony to Congress as FAA Administrator after September 11th. Out of office, she has been executive vice president of the transportation practice at the Washington lobbying firm APCO Worldwide. She has also served the boards of Mitre, the Flight Safety Foundation, and Canadian aircraft manufacturer Bombardier She currently serves as the chairwoman of the Capital-to-Capital Coalition, which advocates for nonstop commercial air service between Beijing and Washington Dulles International Airport and head of U.S. public-private partnerships at JPMorgan

Downey also has had a long career in public transportation administration. His educational background includes graduation with honors from Yale University in 1958, a master's degree in public administration from New York University in 1966, and the Harvard Business School Advanced Management Program in 1988. He worked in administration for the Port Authority of New York, as a congressional transportation analyst, Assistant Secretary for Budget and Programs at the Department of Transportation in the Carter Administration, executive director and chief financial officer at the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) in New York. In the Clinton Administration, he was Deputy Secretary of USDOT and was the Department’s Chief Operating Officer. Out of office, he has been with Parsons Brinckerhoff, an international engineering and transportation consulting firm.

Heminger is the executive director of Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) in the San Francisco Bay area and has served on the National Surface Transportation Policy and Revenue Study Commission. He received his M.A. from the University of Chicago and a B.A. from Georgetown University.

The transition team also has considered Rep. James L. Oberstar, D-Minn., chairman of the House Transportation Committee, and Rep. Peter A. DeFazio, D-Ore., chairman of its highways and transit subcommittee.

I haven't yet seen speculation in the press about who might be the new FMCSA chief, but stay tuned.

Continue reading " Who will be new Secretary of Transportation and director of Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration? " »

Posted On: December 9, 2008

Atlanta motorist killed in collision with tractor trailer on Campbellton Road

As an Atlanta trucking accident lawyer, I am always saddened to hear of yet another needless fatality on our metro roads and highways. This morning there was yet another report of the driver of a passenger vehicle being killed in an encounter with a tractor trailer, this time on Campbellton Road between Fulton Industrial Boulevard and the Chattahoochee River. The AJC report by Mike Morris said nothing about the cause of the crash.

I can't really speculate about the cause of the fatal crash. However, we can be sure that the trucking company and its insurance company had a rapid response team on the scene before the debris was cleared to preserve (or not) the evidence and if possible influence the course of the investigation. That is standard operating procedure in the trucking industry, so it is essential for anyone who has been in a catastrophic truck collision, or lost a family member in one, to promptly contact a lawyer who knows the ropes in trucking cases in order to preserve evidence before it gets away.


Continue reading " Atlanta motorist killed in collision with tractor trailer on Campbellton Road " »

Posted On: December 8, 2008

Truck safety and law implications of Futurist predictions

As a trial lawyer in Atlanta, Georgia, focused largely on motor carrier (tractor trailer, big rig, truck and bus) accident practice, I work every day with the practical realities of individual lawsuits. However, it is useful to also look beyond the horizon at trends that will affect our clients and our practice in years ahead.

Anyone who thinks that current trends will always continue need only look at the discontinuities caused by numerous pivotal events in our lifetime. The internet, cell phones and 9/11 come immediately to mind. In fact, it is almost certain that all trends will be disrupted, sooner or later. Therefore, we need to think about both continuity and discontinuity in guessing where we may be in 10 or 20 years.

Each year the editors of THE FUTURIST pick their top 10 forecasts for their annual Outlook report. Over the years, Outlook has forecast developments as the Internet, virtual reality, and the end of the Cold War. Here some notes of the top 10 forecasts from Outlook 2009 with my rambling thoughts about the implications for trucking safety, law and litigation:

1. "Everything you say and do will be recorded by 2030. By the late 2010s, ubiquitous, unseen nanodevices will provide seamless communication and surveillance among all people everywhere. . . "

The most obvious implication for trucking safety and litigation would be universal electronic data recording on all vehicles. Accident reconstruction would become both more complex and more certain as all speeds and forces would be recorded. Truckers' hours of service would be known and not the subject of "comic book" logs. Litigation of truck accidents would be both simpler and more complex, as facts could be determined with greater certainty but through a process requiring greater technological sophistication. Those of us handling truck accident litigation may need to retrain ourselves with greater sophistication in information technology.


2. "Bioviolence will become a greater threat as the technology becomes more accessible. Emerging scientific disciplines (notably genomics, nanotechnology, and other microsciences) could pave the way for a bioattack. . . . "

New threats will lead to new security measures. Expect tighter security measures to prevent weapons of mass destruction from being shipped in freight containers through our ports and transported on trucks. Detection devices capable of screening freight containers for all biological and nuclear weapons must be developed and deployed.

3. "The car’s days as king of the road may soon be over. More powerful wireless communication that reduces demand for travel, flying delivery drones to replace trucks, and policies to restrict the number of vehicles owned in each household are among the developments that could thwart the automobile’s historic dominance on the environment and culture. If current trends were to continue, the world would have to make way for a total of 3 billion vehicles on the road by 2025."

I'm skeptical about flying delivery drones replacing trucks. If so, truck crash may take on a whole new meaning. However, it is more conceivable that infrastructure improvements could lead to electronic traffic control in dedicated truck lanes, in which driver fatigue and interaction with passenger vehicles would be greatly reduced, thereby improving safety.

4. Careers, and the college majors for preparing for them, are becoming more specialized. . . .

The transportation industry may develop greater professionalism as the use of sophisticated technology further proliferates. Qualifications for safety managers, operations managers and even drivers may rise. Likewise, claims adjusting, investigation and litigation (on both sides) will require greater technical sophistication and specialization.


5. "There may not be world law in the foreseeable future, but the world’s legal systems will be networked. . . . "

Just as economies are increasingly networked and interdependent through modern means of communication and travel, the traditional balkanization of legal systems and the legal profession is changing. Most U.S. states have adopted multijurisdictional practice rules. Before long I expect will very apply not just to U.S. lawyers but to lawyers with which we have trade treaties. Expanding multijurisdictional practice rules to Canadian lawyers would be an easy first step. In the trucking safety field, we may see increasing standardization of truck safety rules between the U.S. and Europe. That would represent a vast upgrade in U.S. trucking safety standards.


6. "Professional knowledge will become obsolete almost as quickly as it’s acquired. An individual’s professional knowledge is becoming outdated at a much faster rate than ever before. Most professions will require continuous instruction and retraining. Rapid changes in the job market and work-related technologies will necessitate job education for almost every worker. At any given moment, a substantial portion of the labor force will be in job retraining programs."


We all must be lifelong learners. Increasingly sophisticated technology will require that everyone in the trucking industry go through regular retraining. Companies that provide training programs should do well. Trucking companies that do not invest in retraining will not survive.

Lawyers who litigate trucking cases must also invest in perpetual retraining. Though I have over 30 years experience as a trial lawyer, I get 60 or 70 hours of continuing legal education credit every year, in the best national programs I can find, compared to the mere 12 hours of CLE required by Bar rules. There is a long list of highly technical courses in the field that I plan to complete when time permits. Of course, with more internet delivery of educational programs, much more will be available everywhere. Those who do not continually retrain in any field will fall behind.

7. "The race for biomedical and genetic enhancement will-in the twenty-first century-be what the space race was in the previous century."

I'm not smart enough to see how this will affect trucking safety or litigation in my time.

8. "Urbanization will hit 60% by 2030. As more of the world’s population lives in cities, rapid development to accommodate them will make existing environmental and socioeconomic problems worse. Epidemics will be more common due to crowded dwelling units and poor sanitation. Global warming may accelerate due to higher carbon dioxide output and loss of carbon-absorbing plants."

See # 2 above. Increased competition for resources and worsening living conditions can easily feed instability, increasing security threats.

9. The Middle East will become more secular while religious influence in China will grow. Popular support for religious government is declining in places like Iraq, according to a University of Michigan study. The researchers report that in 2004 only one-fourth of respondents polled believed that Iraq would be a better place if religion and politics were separated. By 2007, that proportion was one-third. Separate reports indicate that religion in China will likely increase as an indirect result of economic activity and globalization.

This may be a countervailing force with regard to security threats discussed above. Less religious fanaticism in the Middle East and more religious faith in China looks good from where I sit. If we could see more positive influence of religion in our own country, that would be positive too.

10. Access to electricity will reach 83% of the world by 2030. Electrification has expanded around the world, from 40% connected in 1970 to 73% in 2000, and may reach 83% of the world’s people by 2030. Electricity is fundamental to raising living standards and access to the world’s products and services. Impoverished areas such as sub-Saharan Africa still have low rates of electrification; for instance, Uganda is just 3.7% electrified.

Rural electrification came to most of the U.S. when my parents were young. In my father's early childhood, the children studied by the light of kerosene lamps. He has clear memories of when they electric lines reached their home, bringing a radio and much broader access to the world.

When remote and poverty stricken areas of the world get access to electricity, they will be plunged immediately into the world economy and culture through television and the internet. Services that are now outsourced to India may tomorrow be outsourced to Uganda or Rwanda. Internet scams that today emerge from Nigeria may tomorrow be centered in Rwanda or Angola.

With access to the world culture and economy, youth in those areas will have a revolution of rising expectations, which may provide eager volunteers for terrorist or criminal groups. See discussion of security concerns above.

With greater access to electricity, Third World youth will also have greater access to education and opportunities to learn English. To the extent they can obtain visas to enter the U.S. -- or enter illegally -- they will be eager applicants to fill the lower economic rungs many industries, including trucking. To the extent that a new loophole created by the Georgia Court of Appeals is permitted to stand, then we can expect trucking companies to go through their designated agents to hire Third World drivers without even a CDL qualification driving unregulated trucks in order to totally evade all financial responsibility to injured members of the public.

Like weather forecasts, predictions by futurists are often wrong. However, if you don't keep an eye out for the waves you aren't likely to catch one. In the words of Shakespeare's Brutus:

There is a tide in the affairs of men. Which, taken at the flood, leads on to fortune; Omitted, all the voyage of their life Is bound in shallows and in miseries. On such a full sea are we now afloat, And we must take the current when it serves, Or lose our ventures. Julius Caesar Act 4, scene 3, 218–224


Continue reading " Truck safety and law implications of Futurist predictions " »

Posted On: December 8, 2008

Recession hits trucking industry hard

As an Atlanta trial lawyer who does a lot of work in truck and bus accident cases, I am acutely aware of the symbiotic relationship between consumers, retailers, manufacturers, transportation, insurance, and the legal profession. We are all linked together.

Few sectors of the economy are as economically sensitive as freight transportation. And we certainly see it in the current deep recession, as economic downturn has brought a sharp decline in discretionary consumer spending, which is deeply cuts the amount of merchandise shipped to retailers, cutting in turn the demand for shipping.

The U.S. DOT estimates the amount of freight shipped in the U.S. dropped 4.3 percent in August and September.

An investment banking firm recently reported that 127,000 trucks, or 6.5 percent of the country’s fleet, have been idled.

Some 2,609 trucking firms with five or more rigs have failed this year.

YRC Worldwide, the corporation that owns Raodway and Yellow Freight, reports a 10% decline in revenue and has cut 6% of its workforce.

The good news is that less truck traffic should result in fewer injuries and deaths due to truck accidents. The bad news is that when trucking companies are hard pressed economically, they may be more inclined to cut corners on maintenance and safety management, and truck drivers may be more inclined to ignore hours of service and other safety rules.

Continue reading " Recession hits trucking industry hard " »

Posted On: December 7, 2008

Proposed school bus safety rules give manufacturers immunity

We have seen years of criticism of the lack of seat belts and inadequate passenger protection on school buses and other buses. In the next few days, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) is expected to issue a final rule that will require seatbelts for small school buses but only recommends seatbelts for larger school buses. Larger buses will be required to increase the seat back height four inches, at somewhat less cost than adding seat belts.

The rule also includes preemption language that seeks to give blanket immunity to the industry that manufactures buses and their parts. The language would make it much more difficult to recover damages children seriously injured or killed in school bus accidents.

This is just one of numerous regulations that the outgoing administration is seeking to finalize before inauguration day on January 20th, while departing officials seek to feather their nests for new jobs in the industries they have been regulating. Finalizing a regulation before the change of administrations would make it much more difficult for the new administration to change the regulation.

Continue reading " Proposed school bus safety rules give manufacturers immunity " »

Posted On: December 6, 2008

Recession hardship for injury victims prompts attorney fee discount

Individuals and families who suffer catastrophic loss due to trucking accidents always face hardship. In the midst of a the worst recession in a generation, the hardship is often even greater. Responding to that harsh reality facing our potential clients, I have adopted a new fee schedule that cuts average fees by more than 10%. And, as my own small scale "bailout plan" for injured individuals, I have adopted a new lower fee category for early settlements.

This fee schedule applies only to select auto and truck accident cases in which I am hired directly by an individual or family who assists by gathering police reports, photos, medical bills, and certified copies of medical records. I don't accept every case, and do require full disclosure of factors in the client's background that could adversely affect value of the case. Higher fees percentages apply to other categories of cases, such as products liability, professional liability, etc.

Recession Fee Schedule

Settlement within 45 days after sending demand package to insurance company and before suit is filed.

Normal Rate: 33 1/3%
Recession Rate: 25% (new early settlement category)

This discounted fee rate is available only if I am hired within one year after the accident and the client obtains the police reports and medical bills and records. Early settlements are seldom optimal settlements, but the decision belongs to the client.


Settlement after suit filed and before entry of pre-trial order

Normal Rate: 33 1/3%
Recession Rate: 29%

Settlement between entry of pre-trial order and conclusion of trial

Normal Rate: 40%
Recession Rate: 35%

Settlement on post-trial appeal, after appeal brief written

Normal Rate: 45%
Recession Rate: 40%

If I advance litigation expenses for experts, depositions, etc., as is usually necessary, I will be reimbursed at the time of settlement. I use a line of credit for funding of litigation expenses and pass through to the client the actual interest charged on those funds.

All contingent fees are calculated as a percentage of the total amount recovered from the party at fault or its insurance company. Representation includes efforts to negotiate compromises with lienholders, but any legally enforceable lien for medical expenses, etc., must be paid out of the client's share of any recovery.

In trucking cases that go to trial, we sometimes have opportunities to add to other damages a claim for attorney fees and expenses. For example, violations of mandatory motor carrier safety rules may be the basis for a jury to add an award for attorney fees for "bad faith" The extent to which an insurance company explicitly considers a claim for fees and expenses in pre-trial negotiation varies.

Call (877) 778-7944 (toll free) or contact us online.

Continue reading " Recession hardship for injury victims prompts attorney fee discount " »

Posted On: December 5, 2008

Senate Committee critical of Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration

As a trucking accident attorney representing people seriously injured by large trucks, and the families of people who are killed, I work almost every day with the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations, and try to keep up with trucking safety regulation.

Looking forward to transition at the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, it is interesting to look back at what the U.S. Senate Appropriations Committee said in a report on the FMCSA last July. Here are a few excerpts:

The FMCSA has shown a pattern of undermining its safety mission by proposing weak regulations and failing to provide adequate oversight and enforcement of existing regulations.

The rules that FMCSA has proposed fail to achieve maximum safety benefits, and in some instances may undermine safety.

While marginal gains were made in 2007 compared to 2006, the charts show that over two-thirds of inspections continue to uncover violations, and one in five trucks or drivers inspected have violations so severe that they are immediately placed out of service. FMCSA has a great deal of work to do to compel industry compliance.

Continue reading " Senate Committee critical of Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration " »

Posted On: December 4, 2008

Fiery truck crash kills great-grandmother in Virginia

On I-95 in Virginia on December 1, a woman was killed when her Honda SUV was rear-ended by a tractor-trailer in a six-vehicle crash, and was wedged beneath the truck when it ignited. Kamala St. Germain, 75, was the founder of DoveStar, a massage and alternative healing school with locations in several states.

Ironically, before I read of the crash in the media, an eyewitness to the crash contacted me with the following observation:

Witnessed horrific accident I-95 Virginia December 1. One car completely destroyed by fire, a tanker, several cars overturned and one actually split in half.

None of the media accounts I have seen identified the trucking company or touched on the causes of the crash. While it is dangerous to jump to conclusions, usually when we dig into these types of incidents, we find that the truck driver was severely fatigued, taking prescription or over the counter medications that affected his attentiveness, going too fast for conditions, or some combination of the three.

Continue reading " Fiery truck crash kills great-grandmother in Virginia " »

Posted On: December 4, 2008

Two cement truck rollovers in news this week

This week there have been two news bulletins about cement truck rollover which, fortunately, did not cause any serious injuries. It could be a lot worse.

I learned through one recent case that standard concrete industry truck driver training materials emphasize how handling characteristics of such vehicles differ from other trucks. With the high center of gravity and rotating load, concrete mixer trucks can easily roll over. Industry training materials illustrate how a mixer truck will roll over at 16 mph in making a ninety degree turn on a level surface.

In a recent case, a concrete mixer truck rolled over onto a vehicle, cracking the skull of a baby his in infant seat. The truck driver admitted he was going about 25 mph when he made the turn, that he had never been trained to know the speed at which a concrete mixer truck would roll over, and would never have taken a turn as fast as 16 mph if he had known. That case, which included a claim against the concrete company for negligent training and supervision, settled.

Continue reading " Two cement truck rollovers in news this week " »

Posted On: December 4, 2008

Truck driver medical screening and licenses to be linked

In my truck and bus accident law practice in Atlanta, Georgia, I often find truck drivers who were not medically qualified to drive large commercial trucks.

We had one recent case where the driver who caused a crash was blind in one eye, a condition which disqualifies him from even obtaining a Commercial Driver's License in any state. His lack of depth perception combined with excessive speed led to a head-on collision when he swerved around a vehicle that slowed to turn.

In another case the truck driver had COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder), which also is a disqualifying condition. I took the deposition of his personal physician who testified that he had told the truck driver to use supplemental oxygen at all times, 24/7, and that it was unsafe for him to drive a truck.

We also see truckers whose medical conditions require them to take medications with side effects that make it dangerous for them to drive.

Now the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is taking a step in the right direction. It will require states to merge commerical truck and bus drivers licenses and drivers' medical examination certificates into a single electronic record. Linking the two will enable states to check whether drivers have met medical requirements to operate commercial vehicles. The FMCSA also proposed creating a list of medical examiners qualified to award certificates to drivers.

A study released earlier this year found hundreds of thousands of drivers operating trucks and buses even though they had qualified for Social Security medical disability payments.

As I said earlier, this is a step in the right direction. However, it apparently will not require the examiners to look at the drivers' personal medical records. Thus, there is little protection against drivers concealing a history of disqualifying conditions that may not be immediately apparent in an exam.

There is also no requirement to screen for chronic obstructive sleep apnea, which is common among truck drivers and contributes to an untold number of fatigue-related crashes. However, we often see truckers who resist even going to a doctor for evaluation because they known diagnosis could endanger their driving jobs. I can certainly understand the fears of such drivers, but any disqualifying condition that is left untreated can pose a lethal risk to other motorists on the highway.


Continue reading " Truck driver medical screening and licenses to be linked " »

Posted On: December 3, 2008

The future of intellligent transportation systems

While I make my living and support my family as a trial lawyer representing people badly in hurt in truck and bus crashes -- and the surviivors of those who do not survive -- the ultimate objective is to improve safety and reduce the incidence of future injuries and deaths.

While much of safety management in trucking is just common sense and effective management, technology can also provide tools to improve safety. Last month in New York, the 15th World Congress on Intelligent Transportation Systems exhibited several new advances in trucking safety technology. Of course, it will help improve safety only if it is purchased and used.

* Integrated corridor management would use "congestion pricing" to address regional traffic problems. Congestion pricing is the practice of charging more to use a roadway, bridge or tunnel during periods of the heaviest use in order to ease traffic.

* Integrated Vehicle-Based Safety Systems (IVBSS) combines lane departure warning, forward collision warning and blind-spot monitoring into a single system, eliminating distracting and competing warning signals for drivers. Volvo demonstrated a version of VBSS that uses active steering control to keep the vehicle in its lane and to help avoid blind-side collisions in lane changes, as well as providing object detection alerts and rollover warning. The Nissan version of VBSS includes active braking tied to forward and rearward object detection as well as a variety of warning systems based on two-way “cooperative” communications between the vehicle, roadside signals and other nearby vehicles.

* “Trusted Truck” technology would allow heavy vehicles to bypass roadside inspections by use of truck sensors and real-time two-way wireless communications to provide roadside officers with vehicle safety information as the truck approaches the inspection site. An onboard screen then instructs the driver to either bypass the inspection if there are no problems or to pull over. The Volvo system also automatically alerts fleet management if the truck is stopped, providing data on the detected vehicle problems.

* Advanced electronic freight management systems.

* Initiatives to increase truck-parking access.


Continue reading " The future of intellligent transportation systems " »

Posted On: December 1, 2008

$23.5 million verdict against Swift Transportation for spinal cord injury to Yellow Freight employee

A Kansas federal court jury has awarded a $23.5 million verdict for a serious spinal cord injury arising from a 2006 wreck in New Mexico, according to a news story by Ron Sylvester of the Wichita Eagle. The judge reduced the amount to $15.3 million because the jury decided the driver of the other truck was only 65 percent at fault.

A Swift Transportation truck driver was backing up from a rest stop onto the highway when she hit a Yellow Freight truck. The driver of the Swift Transportation truck tested positive for methamphetamine but claimed she was rear-ended. Accident reconstruction proved that story to be false.

The driver of the Yellow Freight truck was killed and the passenger / co-driver had a severe spinal cord injury. This verdict was for the spinal cord injury victim. The wrongful death case is set for trail next spring.

This was not the biggest verdict against Swift Transportation. Last year an Arizona jury awarded $36.5 million to the family of a man killed in a collision with Swift trucks.

At this firm we frequently represent truck drivers who are injured by the negligence of other truckers.

Continue reading " $23.5 million verdict against Swift Transportation for spinal cord injury to Yellow Freight employee " »

Posted On: December 1, 2008

Report on the Motor Carrier Safety Advisory Committee (MCSAC)

This morning I monitored a telephone conference meeting of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's Motor Carrier Safety Advisory Committee (MCSAC).

They will have a two day meeting in Washington on December 9th and 10th to work on a letter report to the Administrator outlining

- innovative safety initiatives and programs that have the potential to reduce the number of truck and bus fatalities,
- research and development activiites to assess the potential for new safety technologies, and
- enhanced driver qualification standards and driver safey fitness ratings.

Much of the discussion was about semantics -- use of the term "public-private partnerships." They finally agreed to tweak the language to make it clear that they were not talking only about public-private partnerships.

There are two openings on the committee for law enforcement representatives. Nominations are due by this Thursday, December 4th.

Continue reading " Report on the Motor Carrier Safety Advisory Committee (MCSAC) " »